pwa compliance, certified payroll, wh-347, prevailing wage · · 6 min read
The Wage Rate Is Right and the Worker Is Still Underpaid
A certified payroll can show the right wage rate while an unauthorized deduction takes money back out. Here’s how to verify what’s inside the “Other” box.
Every wage rate on a certified payroll report can be right, and a worker can still be underpaid. Say an employer takes $40 for a tool charge the worker never agreed to. It lands in “Other,” the one box on the weekly form for every deduction that isn’t a tax. A $340 total there could be $200 of child support and a $140 health premium. It could also be $200 of child support, a $100 health premium, and that $40. Nothing in the total tells a reviewer which, and the report gets signed either way.
What an employer can take back out of the check
Prevailing wage rules set a floor on what a worker earns, and restrict what an employer can take back out of the check. The Copeland Act regulations allow a short list of deductions without Department of Labor approval, including taxes, court-ordered payments, and benefit-plan contributions the worker consented to in writing or a union agreement covers.[1] Everything else needs that approval before it ever touches a paycheck.[2] An unauthorized deduction is an underpayment wearing a disguise. The gross wage on the form looks right while the net wage in the worker’s pocket is wrong.
The signature covers deductions too
A contractor signing the statement of compliance is certifying that no deductions were made, directly or indirectly, other than the ones the law permits.[3] That sits in the same certification as the wage statement, and willfully falsifying it can be prosecuted as a federal crime, punishable by a fine, up to five years in prison, or both.[4]
Column 8 gives every deduction one box
The government’s payroll form, known as WH-347, gives that signature exactly one column for anything that isn’t a tax. Column 8 has slots for withholding, FICA, and “Other.”[5] Child support, a garnishment, a health-plan election, a 401(k) contribution, union dues: all of it lands in the same box, as one number. The form’s own instructions say that if “Other” covers more than one deduction, the contractor has to attach an addendum itemizing each one, with a description and an amount.[5] A single deduction gets described under Additional Remarks instead.[5] In practice, that addendum is the first thing to go missing.
The documents that settle what is in the total
A total on its own proves nothing. Column 8 shows the same $340 whether or not the tool charge is in it.
The first document that can say what is inside that $340 is the payroll deduction authorization, the worker’s own signed consent, on file with the employer, naming each voluntary deduction, its amount, and when it started.[6] A court order covers the involuntary ones.[1] A collective bargaining agreement covers union dues and any benefit contributions it provides for.[1] Together, those three are the source of truth for what should be coming out of a paycheck, the same way an apprenticeship certificate is the source of truth for whether someone can legally be paid the apprentice rate.
How to reconcile an “Other” total
Reconciling the payroll against those documents is mechanical once they are in hand. If the payroll itemizes each deduction, every line has to match an authorization, a court order, or the union agreement. When the payroll shows only the “Other” total, that total has to equal the sum of what those documents cover for that worker, that week, rounding aside. Anything that doesn’t match is either an unauthorized deduction or a missing document, and both need an answer from the contractor.
A total with no itemization and no backing document is an unverified certification, whatever the signature claims.
Why this goes unchecked
Most project owners never ask for the authorizations. They sit in a contractor’s internal HR file, and most compliance checklists never list them as a document to request. Contractors rarely send authorizations unprompted. Projects can reach closeout with every “Other” total unverified and every certification signed anyway.
Ask for it at onboarding
The fix belongs earlier than closeout. Add the payroll deduction authorization to the document request that goes out to every subcontractor at onboarding, and it’s on file before there’s anything to reconcile.
What to ask for:
- The payroll deduction authorization for every worker with a nonzero “Other” total.
- Any court order backing an involuntary deduction.
- The collective bargaining agreement wherever union dues or benefit contributions run through it.
- A weekly itemization of “Other,” not just when a reviewer happens to ask for one.
The itemization lets an auditor verify each amount. Never assume. If the paper isn’t there, go back to the contractor for it.
The point
Once every “Other” total on a project ties to a document, it’s handled. And whoever signs for the project can sign with certainty.
Sources
Where this comes from: the Copeland Act regulations, 29 CFR part 3, and the payroll certification rules at 29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii). Both were written for Davis-Bacon work. Clean energy tax credit projects aren’t required to file certified payroll, but most use it, and the same reconciliation applies. A state prevailing-wage program layered on top of a project can carry its own deduction rules, which this piece doesn’t cover.
- 29 CFR 3.5, payroll deductions permissible without application to or approval of the Secretary of Labor. Paragraph (a) covers deductions required by law, such as taxes. Paragraph (c) covers amounts required by court process to be paid to another. Paragraph (d) covers contributions to benefit plans, which require either the worker’s voluntary written consent in advance, (d)(2)(i), or a bona fide collective bargaining agreement, (d)(2)(ii). The same section permits union dues where a collective bargaining agreement provides for them.
- 29 CFR 3.6, which lets a contractor apply to the Secretary of Labor for permission to make a deduction 3.5 doesn’t allow, and the U.S. Department of Labor’s WH-347 instructions, which say that apart from the deductions listed in 29 CFR 3.5, all deductions need prior approval from the Department of Labor.
- 29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii)(C), the Statement of Compliance. Paragraph (C)(2) is the certification that no deductions were made from the full wages earned, other than permissible deductions as set out in 29 CFR part 3.
- 29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii)(F), which says falsifying the certifications can bring civil or criminal liability under 18 U.S.C. 1001 and 31 U.S.C. 3729. Under 18 U.S.C. 1001(a), a knowing and willful false statement in a federal matter is punishable by a fine, imprisonment of not more than 5 years, or both.
- U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, Form WH-347 (Payroll) and its instructions, https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/forms/wh347. The instructions describe Column 8 and the itemized addendum for “Other” deductions.
- 29 CFR 3.5(d)(2)(i), (f), (g), and (j)(1), which make written or voluntary authorization from the worker a condition of the deductions they cover.
This post is educational and is not legal advice. Deduction rules can differ under state prevailing-wage programs, so a compliance professional should confirm how they apply to a specific project.